Noir Beta 反馈 · 产品评审

Feedback 1

1. no way to pay gas on the Private account. it starts with 0 ETH, so my first swap there failed with "Insufficient native balance", and i only found out after clicking Swap. the obvious fix is sending ETH from Public, but that links Public and Private on-chain which kinda defeats the point. i ended up moving ETH Public -> Shield -> Private by hand to keep them separate. would be great to have gas paid in USDC, or a one-click "top up gas via Shield", and at least show the warning before i hit Swap
2. when moving Shield -> Private, picking the token silently changed the destination from Private to Public. i caught it before confirming, but someone could easily send their Shield funds back to Public without noticing
3. in the token picker, the list keeps reshuffling while it says "Searching more networks...". i clicked ETH on Base and it selected ETH on Arbitrum because the rows moved under my cursor
4. the Move screen sometimes preselects the right token on the wrong chain. e.g. it picked USDC on a chain where i have 0, so it showed "0 Max", even though my USDC was on Base. both look identical so for a sec i thought my funds were gone
5. the asset list under the Public tab shows the total across Public + Shield + Private, not just Public. my USDC showed 4.49 when Public only had 3 (the rest was 1 in Shield and 0.49 in Private). i thought the balance was stuck until i checked on-chain
6. when i opened Swap from the Private tab, the "From" was set to Zcash Shield with ZEC (0 balance) instead of my Private account. had to change both the token and the account manually
7. the seed confirmation step (pick the 3rd and 10th word) shows all 24 words in plain text, just shuffled. the screen right before it blurs them, so this one kinda undoes that
smaller stuff:
- the same kind of action gets different labels. my Public -> Shield move showed as "Receive -2 USDC" in the progress popup and activity list, while Shield -> Private showed as "Send". calling both "Move" would be clearer
- on the Move screen the main button said "Review Cluster" at first, then changed to "Move". not sure what cluster means there
- the swap progress screen lists two transactions both labeled "Base Tx". would help to say which is the outgoing one and which is the incoming one
- on create password, the strength meter pops in and pushes the confirm field down while you type, so i clicked the wrong spot
- the Continue button on the invite code screen works even with the field empty
- after my first deposit it took about a minute for the balance to show up, with no loading hint
moving between Public, Shield and Private plus a swap on Private all went through fast and landed as estimated, and the confirm screens are really clear. works very well in Brave
haven't tried some of the other features yet, but will do when i find more time
thanks again for the invite, hope this is helpful!

Feedback 2

[截图1][截图2]
Jemartel.near:
This ui show up when you want to add a wallet
Jemartel.near:
I fid kinda oddd

Feedback 3

Main pain point: UFVK setup
LiveZEC needs a user's unified full viewing key (UFVK) to scan the chain through Zkool_GraphQL. That's how it picks up incoming transactions with memos and shows them on the overlay.
Most users don't know what a UFVK is, and few wallets make it easy to export. Some don't expose it at all.
Ask: let users export the UFVK directly through the Noir SDK, so integrations and onboarding are smoother.
LiveZEC recommends users create a fresh wallet just for LiveZEC.
Login
Logging in with recovery seeds is clunky. A more direct login method would improve UX.
Michae2xl suggested Noir could handle both login and adding a Zcash account via viewing key.
Feedback on Noir's current wallet
Confirmation times are long (3x for sending, 10x for receiving). Can they be shortened?
The balance sometimes doesn't sync until the pop-up is closed and reopened.
Noir's follow-ups
Asked about Keystone support, a viewing key option, and security features other wallets offer that Noir doesn't.
Proposed making the extension pinnable, like MetaMask. Michae2xl liked the idea.
Action items for Noir: UFVK export (in the app and SDK), simpler login, faster confirmations, a fix for the balance sync bug, and a pinnable extension.
[截图1]

原文附图：密钥原理图，不是钱包故障截图。